ECG Vs 2D ECHO: Difference Between Electrocardiogram and Echocardiography

Both 2D echo and ECG are two common and the most performed tests for checking heart health. They serve different purposes, yet they complement each other in diagnosis. A 2D echo using ultrasounds produces real-time images of the heart.

‍

These images give information as to how well the heart is functioning and if there are issues with its structures, such as valve problems or weak heart muscles. An ECG, on the other hand, records the electrical signals produced and helps to detect irregular heart rhythms, heart attacks.

‍

Choosing between a 2D echo and an ECG depends on the symptoms and what the doctor needs to know. This blog explains when each test is used and how they work.

‍

What is 2-Dimensional Echocardiography?

2-Dimensional echocardiography helps to visualize a beating heart by ultrasound waves generated from a hand-held device, the transducer. The transducer contains a piezoelectric crystal, which produces sound waves when varying voltages are applied. The sound waves produced are reflected off the different heart tissues towards which the device is pointed.

‍

The device captures the signals from the crystals in the receiving mode and converts them to electric signals, which then form an image of the heart on the monitor. Transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) is the standard among the types of echocardiography.

‍

Working principle of echocardiography

TTE is based on the principle that ultrasound waves of frequency greater than 20 kilohertz (inaudible to the human ear) are poorly transmitted through bone and air but are reflected at the boundaries between the two tissues. Thus, by holding a transducer at various locations in the chest, known as the acoustic windows, 2D images of the heart are made from various angles that can be penetrated.

‍

Why is a 2D echo done?

A 2D echo helps to detect various heart diseases and problems. A 2D echo test helps in gaining a better understanding of the following.

‍

1. To determine the size and shape of the heart and its chambers:

• High blood pressure results in the enlargement of the heart.

• Enlargement of the ventricles, the lower chambers of the heart, occurs, causing insufficient pumping of blood.

‍

2. Pericardium (The sac that surrounds the heart): A fluid buildup in the pericardium compresses the heart, leading to a fall in BP, quiet heart sounds, shortness of breath, weakness, and cough.

‍

3. Heart muscles: Heart attacks lead to the weakening of heart muscles and a decrease the blood supply to the heart.

‍

4. Heart valves: It helps to correlate the symptoms of malfunctioning valves, such as fatigue, leg swelling, and changes in heart sounds on auscultation.

‍

5. Blood clots: Patients with a history of stroke require an echo to detect the location and extent of heart tissue damage.

‍

6. Congenital heart defects: Congenital heart problems, like a hole in the heart wall, can be identified through a 2D echo.

‍

What is an Electrocardiogram, ECG?

ECG is a simple, non-invasive test that records the heart's electrical activity. Every heartbeat produces an electrical impulse that causes the heart to contract and pump blood. ECG captures these electrical impulses and creates a graphical waveform. It helps healthcare professionals analyze heart rhythm, rate, and function.

‍

Why is an ECG done?

‍

ECG tells us about:

• Time taken for an electrical pulse to travel through the heart.

• Areas of the heart that are overworked or too large.

‍

A doctor determines how long it takes for the electrical pulse to travel through the heart by calculating time intervals on the ECG. It indicates that electrical activity is natural in strength, erratic, sluggish, or fast.

‍

By telling us how long it takes for the impulse to travel from one part of the heart to the other. A cardiologist can identify the areas in the heart that are overworked by measuring the amount of electrical activity that flows through the heart muscles.

‍

Working of ECG

Ten electrodes are placed on the arms, legs, and chest. The average strength of these electric impulses is calculated from different angles and reported over 10 seconds. Throughout the cardiac cycle, the intensity and trajectory of the electrical depolarization are observed.

‍

Why are ECG and Echo Tests Needed?

ECG (electrocardiograph) and echo (echocardiogram) tests are central tools for assessing heart health. People require the test for various reasons, like chest pain, shortness of breath, palpitations, or dizziness. An ECG provides information about the electrical activity going on within the heart and helps to detect arrhythmias, heart attacks, or other issues.

‍

It is done first because of ease and speed. An echo is recommended for a detailed evaluation. It helps to visualize the heart's structure and function. Doctors can assess heart failure, valve disorders, or congenital heart defects. Both tests are non-invasive and play an important role in diagnosing and monitoring heart health.

‍

Which test is recommended and when?

ECG and 2D-echo are complementary tools. Each has a unique role in heart health assessment. They are recommended for the following reasons.

Differences in Uses: 2D Echo Versus ECG

‍

‍

Important Symptoms of Cardiac Health Issues

We must recognize the symptoms of cardiac diseases for early diagnosis and intervention. The symptoms of cardiac diseases appear subtly. This makes awareness, prompt action, and timely medical care necessary. Addressing these signs leads to improved management and prevention of serious complications.

‍

• Chest pain or discomfort feels like a crushing pressure in the chest that spreads to the arms, neck, or jaw, indicating angina or a heart attack.

• Shortness of breath during physical activity or while lying on the bed indicates the heart is not functioning properly. 

• Palpitations, fluttering, or pounding appear as a missed, skipped heartbeat or a in the heart indicating abnormal rhyth.

• Fatigue, unexplained tirednessitIt happens in women and it is a warning of a heart attack even when chest pain does not occur.

• Swelling in legs or ankles: Edema from poor blood circulation, which indicates heart failure.

• Dizziness and Lightheadedness: Reduced blood flow to the brain, often due to arrhythmias or heart attacks, causes fainting.

• Nausea or indigestion, Gastrointestinal discomfort can be a symptom of a typical heart attack.

• Cold sweats: Sudden sweating indicates stress on the heart, especially with chest pain or shortness of breath.

‍

Differences Between 2D Echo and ECG

‍

1. Principle

2D echo uses sound waves to create a detailed image of the heart structure and functions. ECG records the electrical activity of the heart.

‍

2. Procedure

ECG is a quick, non-invasive procedure in which electrodes are placed on the skin of the patient's chest, arms, and legs. These electrodes capture electric signals and display them on a tracing sheet. 2D echo requires a transducer to produce ultrasound images of the heart. The procedure is also non-invasive, but it takes longer to provide detailed images.

‍

3. Result Interpretation

ECG results are reviewed by the healthcare provider instantly. It allows quick diagnosis and treatment decisions. A 2D echo, on the other hand, requires a comprehensive analysis by a cardiologist. It requires intricate details about heart structure and function, hence additional time to interpret.

‍

4. Limitations

ECG does not detect structural abnormalities of the heart, such as valve defects or congenital disabilities. 2D Echo visualizes the heart structures to provide the necessary information.

‍

5. Cost

ECG is less expensive than a 2D echo because it is simple and quick. 2D echo is a costly procedure and needs expertise in interpretation.

‍

6. Frequency of use

It can be easily performed in many healthcare settings like emergency rooms, clinics, and routine check-ups, and is accessible for initial heart evaluations. 2D-Echo can be performed in cardiology clinics or hospitals equipped with ultrasound technology. Making it less readily available for routine procedures.

‍

7. Technology advancements

ECG technology has improved with portable and wearable devices that monitor heart rhythm continuously, helping patients with arrhythmias. 2D echo has advanced with 3D imaging and better techniques that provide a clear view of the heart and improve diagnosis.

‍

Key Differences Between 2D-Echo and ECG

‍

‍

Drawbacks of ECG and 2D echo    

ECG and 2D echo are valuable tools for heart health diagnosis. ECG can assess electrical activity, but cannot assess structural details. 2D echo provides structural images but misses subtle electrical changes. Both produce false positives or negatives, and each test's accuracy depends on operator skills. 

‍

• Echocardiograms do not show coronary arteries and can detect only severe blockages. They cannot measure the heart chamber pressure accurately as sound waves are distorted by fluid. The body structures can sometimes interfere with getting a clear image.

• 2D Echo can detect structural heart defects, but cannot show if they cause symptoms or predict patients' outcomes.

• Echo is a costly procedure due to its technical complexity; it cannot be employed in limited resource areas where cardiac diseases are more prevalent.

‍

Conclusion

ECG and 2D echo are essential diagnostic tools for detecting heart issues, muscle abnormalities, and valve disorders. ECG and 2D echo are inexpensive and non-invasive tests. Understanding the unique strengths and limitations allows us to perform a more comprehensive evaluation of heart health.

‍

Gauze provides solutions for ECG and 2D echo; the choice between ECG and 2D echo depends on patient symptoms, medical history, and clinical needs to ensure the best outcomes.